why choose us

300×250 Ad Slot

Research Article: Horizon scanning, rapid reviews and living evidence to support decision-making: lessons from the work of the Critical Intelligence Unit in New South Wales, Australia during the COVID-19 pandemic

Date Published: 2023-05-18

Abstract:
The COVID-19 pandemic has seen an increase in rapidly disseminated scientific evidence and highlighted that traditional evidence synthesis methods, such as time and resource intensive systematic reviews, may not be successful in responding to rapidly evolving policy and practice needs. In New South Wales (NSW) Australia, the Critical Intelligence Unit (CIU) was established early in the pandemic and acted as an intermediary organisation. It brought together clinical, analytical, research, organisational and policy experts to provide timely and considered advice to decision-makers. This paper provides an overview of the functions, challenges and future implications of the CIU, particularly the Evidence Integration Team. Outputs from the Evidence Integration Team included a daily evidence digest, rapid evidence checks and living evidence tables. These products have been widely disseminated and used to inform policy decisions in NSW, making valuable impacts. Changes and innovations to evidence generation, synthesis and dissemination in response to the COVID-19 pandemic provide an opportunity to shift the way evidence is used in future. The experience and methods of the CIU have potential to be adapted and applied to the broader health system nationally and internationally.

Introduction:
The COVID-19 pandemic has seen an increase in rapidly disseminated scientific evidence. This evidence varies in quality and is often pre-peer review. The pandemic has been described as ‘break(ing) the evidence pipeline’ and traditional evidence synthesis methods, such as systematic reviews, may not be successful; many reviews are out of date before publication. 1 As a result, there has been an increased need for timely and responsive synthesised evidence to inform decision-making. Internationally, different…

Read more

300×250 Ad Slot